The fishlike thing is a strange, already-cooked fish that can only be fished from the coast of Evil Bob's island of ScapeRune. It is obtained from the fishing spot which the servant points out will make Evil Bob fall asleep. In the random event, the player must catch and then uncook the fishlike thing using one of the uncooking pots. After giving the uncooked fishlike thing to Evil Bob, the player will be teleported back to their previous location. Upon catching this creature, the player will receive the message: You catch a... what is this?? Is this a fish?? And... it's cooked already??
If the player tries to eat it, they are prompted with the message: It looks vile and smells even worse. You're not eating that!
After using it with the uncooking pot, it becomes a raw fishlike thing which can be fed to Evil Bob. It cannot be uncooked using a regular log fire, or by any other means. Once uncooked, it cannot be cooked again.
Both the raw and cooked versions can be fed to the player's kitten, though the player will have to speak again to the servant to be able to fish again.
1 
Small fishing net
